Why Assessments?

Better decisions begin with better information.

A practical business case for using job-relevant, professionally selected assessments in the hiring and development process.

The business case

Hiring decisions deserve more than intuition.

A résumé tells you where someone has worked. References and interviews can reveal useful information. But none of these alone provides a complete view of the job-related characteristics that may contribute to success.

The cost of a poor hiring decision can extend beyond recruiting and replacement expenses to include lost productivity, management time, employee turnover, and organizational disruption. The specific cost depends on the role and situation; there is no single reliable cost figure for every employer.

Conventional methods have limitations

Informal, unstructured interviews and résumé reviews may be inconsistent and vulnerable to bias. Structured interviews and job-relevant assessments can help add rigor to the process.

Assessment quality matters

Appropriate, validated instruments can provide additional information about abilities and work-related characteristics. Their value depends on relevance to the job, sound implementation, and careful interpretation.

Evidence, not assumptions

The best approach combines complementary information.

Structured, competency-based interviews are themselves strongly supported by selection research. Carefully selected psychometric instruments can add different job-relevant information. The objective is not to substitute one tool for every other method, but to use complementary evidence appropriately.

Rather than promoting testing as a substitute for human judgment, EAG helps clients build a better-informed picture of candidates through appropriate assessment methods.

More assessment isn't necessarily better assessment. The objective is to choose job-relevant instruments, understand what they do—and do not—measure, and apply the results responsibly.

Selected research and guidance

  1. Sackett and colleagues (2022), reassessment of personnel selection validity estimates. Read publication summary.
  2. U.S. Office of Personnel Management, Assessment and Selection guidance.

Selection tools should be evaluated for their intended purpose, including job relevance and applicable employment requirements.

Let's discuss your assessment needs.

Speak with EAG about choosing and applying the right instruments for your organization.

Start a Conversation